Overall Rating: 5
Price [Value]: 5
Packaging Quality:5
Would you buy this product again? Yes

I really am happy with the Estee Lauder shadows. The staying power was great and the shades are gorgeous. Although lacking the selection of mac I have Plum Pop and Ivy. Ivy is a beautiful green that will compliment many mac shades --Plum pop is a gorgeous matte (well or satin finish?) Plum and these are great fall colors. I plan on getting more estee shadows to compliment my mac collection. The packaging on the shadows is better in a clear fairly flat cube (well flat cube) and have a mirror, my one problem with Estee Lauder is I don't need the mirrors

__________________
JOY
There's no religion but sex and music
There's no religion but sound and dancing
There's no religion but line and color
There's no religion but the endless ocean

Overall rating: 5
Price/Value: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would I buy again?: Yes

Fabulous colors and rich velvety, creamy textured shadow (Velvetier than MAC). The little lucite cubes are adorable. My all time favorite crease color is Mink. My favorite true T'ang Dynasty color is Gold Nugget. The browns and bronzes are the best!!!They also have the most user friendly collection of plums if you don't go for the goth look.

__________________
Russian/Chinese, from planet NARS, age 45. "If its pink and sparkley I will shoot it...."