Lipgelee: Who's That Lady (shimmer, Who's That Lady)

Juneplum · 11-28-2005, 10:43 AM #1 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? Yes

One of the nicer of the 3 lipgelees in this collection. It's a very sheer pink, but has beautiful golden pearly sparkles. On it's own you don't have a big color payoff, but it still gives a nice healthy lip look albeit sparkly

. It can definitely be layered on top of a lipstick or lipliner to kick up the color a notch! I'd buy this again.

ladybugz07 · 11-28-2005, 04:50 PM #2 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? probably

Comments: WTL is a super sheer pink color. It is incredibly sparkly, but there is no color payoff. It's just like adding shimmer to your lips, only it feels better! I was relieved it didn't feel gritty...

bluegrassbabe · 11-28-2005, 09:51 PM #3 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 5
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? Yes
This is not what I was expecting, but I still like it. It is a pale pink color with silvery shimmer. The pink color disappears right into my lip, but the shimmer is super pretty. The best part of it is the texture. It feels wonderful on bare lips, especially if you're dry like me. Can also be used to add some sparkle to lipstick. I wish there were more shimmer lip gelees out there.

stacey · 11-29-2005, 03:50 PM #4 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 2
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? No

This didn't wow me at all. Very very sheer pink, didn't show up on my very well. Maybe that's why I didn't like it that much? Only payoff for me, just like Dame in a Dress, was the glitter otherwise nothing else really got my attention.

jeanna · 12-07-2005, 11:01 AM #5 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 3
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 4
Would you buy this product again? Probably not

This is the only one that appealed to me out of the 3 lipgelees, because I'm more of a pink person more than anything else. On me - I'm an NC30/35 - it shows up clear with a lot of silvery sparkles. The sparkles aren't gritty at all and like all lipgelees, it felt very comfortable on my lips. On it's own, it's nothing special but I could see this looking very nice over a pink lipstick. I also found that while it looks pretty when freshly applied, the shine didn't last very long and within a half hour, I was only left with silver sparkles on my lips and I'd have to re-apply. For now, I've given it a rating of 4 for packaging because originally I was told that they weren't going to be in Canada at all at the time of launch as they were being recalled due to a packaging defect (leaking, etc.) So far so good, but I guess I won't know til later... I'll edit my review if anything changes.

Alannah · 12-09-2005, 05:21 PM #6 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? Probably

I like this quite a bit--it felt really nice and looked good on. I think I would've been disappointed in the lack of tint if I hadn't read these reviews before I tried mine on. I was also probably predisposed to like it just based on the fact that every counter in my area was sold out of this gelee, and I completely lucked out and managed to get one of the last ones... I was just so excited about that that I HAD to like it. Ha ha. If it had a more noticeable tint, I would be absolutely in love with it, but as it is I like it very much.

I have Dame in a Dress as well but haven't tried that yet to compare.

sephirias · 12-20-2005, 01:01 AM #7 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? No

this is a sheer sheer pearly pink l.g. with hints of beige. it is very pretty and chic in the tube. i can see why this will be a hit with ladies. it's quite versatile. however, it's too sticky for my liking.

Monalisa · 01-10-2006, 02:46 AM #8 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is my first lipgelee and I really like the texture and the shimmer!

n_j_t · 01-14-2006, 10:34 AM #9 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 3
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 3
Would you buy this product again? No

It looks lovely in the tube--a pretty pale sparkly pink, and it looks really nice on my pigmented lips (NC35). Has the same nice vanilla-y MAC scent and the texture is okay--I like sticky glosses so I prefer lipglasses. And if it stayed on my lips for more than 10 minutes, I'd give it a higher rating. But the staying power sucks. Too bad.

Hikaru-chan · 02-05-2006, 12:59 PM #10 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 5
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? Yes if it wasn't LE.

Very pretty soft pink with sparkles, looks great over neutral lipstick.

blueaygi · 03-02-2006, 02:41 PM #11 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 5
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would you buy this product again? YES! if i can find anymore!

This is my absolute favorite lipgloss! this is what got me hooked on the lipgelees! its the perfect pink with lots of pretty shimmer! i just wish i could find more of them at reasonable prices =T

Wontpayretail23 · 06-14-2006, 08:53 PM #12 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 5
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 2
Would you buy this product again? YES

I loved this one. I bought 3 back ups and I'm glad I did. I love the shimmer. I have a pic of this gloss and just me wearing the gloss in my FOTD blog (link below). I gave the packaging quality a 2 because I had a Dame in a Dress & a Cool and Aloof both leak all over my pocket because the end split and MAC couldn't replace them because they were LE. Don't let your end split open!

DOLLface · 09-19-2006, 06:48 PM #13 (**permalink**)

Overall Rating: 5
Price: 4
Packaging Quality: 4
Would you buy this product again? Oh yes.

I bought this recently from a lovely Specktra member and have fallen madly in love with it. If I ever come across another I would definately buy it.