Not sure if they're considered rare but seen some people post them up so i've got:

MSF
Porcelain Pink
Northern Lights
Gold Spill

Aquavert e/s
Tectonic e/s

I only get pigment samples so
Soft Washed (Asia exclusive)
Goldenaire
Gold Dusk
Softwashed Grey
Apricot Pink

I don't know if these are rare but I have a lot of LE items:

Raquel Welch Icon stuff:
-Sultress e/s quad
-Screenqueen l/s

Novel Twist
-Pro Brush Set (all SE brushes, 187, 219, some others I forget)

Zandra Rhodes
-Zandra l/s

Alexander McQueen
-New Vegas MSF
-Masque l/s

Barbie
-Style it Up l/s

Fafi
-Sassed Up IP
-Not So Innocent l/s
-2/3 of the dolls

2006 Holiday Lipglass/Lustreglass set with Spring Bean l/g, Wonderstruck, Florabundance, some other ones??? I don't have them here with me...

Other LE/DC'd items
-Overload l/s
-Orchidazzle l/s
-B-Rich e/s
-Fresco l/s
-Rocker l/s
-Porcelain Pink MSF
-Boldheart l/g
-Jewel Blue e/s
-Mint & Olive softsparkle eye pencil
-Shimmertime pigment
-Deckchair pigment, pressed
-Golder's Green pigment, pressed
-Night Light pigment
-Gold Stroke pigment
-Coco Beach pigment sample
-Young Spark l/g
-Northern Lights MSF

Pro products
-Violet pigment sample
-Marine Ultra pigment sample

Accessories
-I have this satin medium sac that's kind of a coppery brown color. I got it at a CCO...dunno when it came out. PLMK of a release for this, TIA

__________________
NC15, black hair, hazel eyes

The only stuff I have that was released prior to 2008 would be 2 Lipsticks,
Oh Sheer Up!
Giggle-Fest

IDK if those are rare Im new to the MAC world :P

The only really rare items I have are hot & sour paint, pretty twisted e/s, and turquoise matte pigment.

__________________


I MAC!

Proud Dazzleglass Bimbo since May 2008!

omg. maybe you can help me. i'm trying to remember the name of a old school lipstick that i used to LOVE in the mid 90's. it was kind of silver/pewtery and was discontinued around 94 or 95.

MAC Playboy Centerfold l/s
Full size All Girl pigment

the only RARE item i own is riot eyeshadow in a screw top pot.

i have some hard-ish to find and/or somewhat pricy items that i wouldn't really consider rare per se;
gold pigment (frost/dc)
all girl pigment
coco beach pigment
maroon pigment
quietly pigment
stereo rose msf
so ceylon msf
petticoat msf

i think that's it.

I dont think any of the MAC items I own are considered rare. I have a few old eyeshadows in the screwtop pots, a lipstick in the old cylindrical packaging and a Slick Cream Color Base. Oh and my friend gives me some of her Gold Dusk pigment since she has a full size jar. Everything else I have is new and normal.

hmmm well these are all the ones i consider to be rare:

All Girl pigment
Sassed Up Beauty Powder (Fafi)
Porcelain Pink MSF (discontinued)
Alpha Girl Beauty Powder (Heatherette, LE and sold out)
Strawberry Blonde Lipstick (my hg lippie)
Love, Henri Lipstick (Henri Bendel exclusive -- had the lipglass too but it was blah)
Marisheeno Lipstick (Asia Exclusive)
Sweet & Single lipstick (Barbie)
Magic Dust eyeshadow (Barbie)
Mercurial and By Jupiter MES (discontinued)
Holiday Coral Lips Palette '07 (Royal Assets)
Heatherette Trio 2 eyeshadow palette (Heatherette, LE and sold out)
Fashion Pack lipglass (Barbie)
Fantastic Plastic CCB (discontinued)
Maidenchant blushcreme (Lure)

and i think that's all

__________________
***Dazzleglass Bimbo for life***
NW20/Green Eyes/Dirty Blonde Untreated Hair

i think the only rare thing i have is the collection of mineralized e/s that came out 2007, i have all 6 that came out, and i hear people rave about the red one (lovestone) all the time.......but i have NEVER used them, that was a lesson learned for me to try things at the counter before i just buy because of the hype....i hope i'll use them one day

I'm very new to MAC so don't even know what all is considered rare yet. I have Aquavert e/s in the green pot which I know is kind of rare. Oh, and the 4 connected Viva Glam postcards.

i've been using MAC for a couple of years and have accumulated a bunch of stuff that i think is "pretty". i am on specktra so i am familiar with the "mac value" of the items i have but no matter how "valuable" something is, i still will use it if i love it instead of preserving it! and if something is bleh on me, i will give it away or swap it no matter how "rare" it is.

i HAD every skinfinish (except for pleasureflush) but sold metal rock, porcelain pink, petticoat, naked you, and stereo rose b/c i didn't think they were that great

i also have original jars of:
gold frost pigment d/c
green frost pigment d/c
maroon pigment d/c
all girl pigment
coco pigment
coco beach pigment
rr blue pigment
deckchair pigment
forest green pigment d/c
i had mustard matte but sold it b/c it was chalky and ugly.
also, these pigments are by no means full anymore b/c i use them often... they're about half full

i also have all the newer l/e eyeshadows: de menthe, parrot, guacamole, goldbit, sprout, elite, lucky green, metamorph, meadowland, sunsplosion, all the tantress, belle azure, barbie, lustrevision collection eyeshadows

zandra lipstick. louella tlcs. blow lipstick. strawberry blonde lipstick. rayothon lipglass. flash of flesh lipglass. bendel lippies. peacocky glitter liner. temperley palette.

i found some oldschool retro mattes in my mom's makeup drawer that smelled funny so i b2m-ed them. *shrug*

i have some diana stuff
i have hot and sour paint.

i have every beauty powder MAC has ever made
i have inventive, pandamonium, liza pm, coprs de colour quads
the holiday palette w/ parrot
postcards dating back to time rocker
mac jewelry / clothing

i also have the new california dramin' lipstick which seems to be popular nowadays...

I have 2 very old brushes which I bought at the Bay in Vancouver: 140 and 2.S and hemp eyeshadow.

I own a SE brush set with it's own brush roll. The brushes are the same quality as the full size brushes, not like the ones in the Holiday sets. I believe this set is approximately 12 years old. I bought it on a whim at Nordstroms because I needed some brushes. I have some other old stuff from back in the day when MAC first came to Nordstrom in the US.

I've been using mac about the past 4 years and been reaching into the past to find many things over those years and have been pretty good at doing so if I do say so my self. However with every other item mac makes if I don't like it, to me it doesn't matter if its rare or not it will get swapped or sold because I don't want to hold onto things that I'll never use, I already have enough with things I love but don't use enough.

I bought and sold all the MSF's and am left with one, because its the only one I have ever even opened to use, I however do not regret it because I never used them and I'm glad they went to good homes where somebody would love them as apposed to sitting in my train case cramped in and getting no use.

for me.. rare is something you don't see up for sale hardly at all been d/c years and years ago.. I have many other things that may or may not be thought of as rare.

I have -

pigments:
Auburn, Black, Blue, Brass, Bronze, Copper, Gold, Green, Green (Matte), Light Blue, Orange, Pink, Purple, Red, Royal Blue, Turquoise, Yellow

paints:
blue boy, hot + sour, infamous

.. I have a few blushes, and maybe a few lipgelee's that might be that way in a few years.

__________________

Let me see, I can't remember all of the rare stuff I have. This is just some of the stuff that comes to mind.

Hot + Sour Paint
Infamous Paint
BlueBoy Paint
Denim Dish Palette
Perverted Pearl Palette
Liza PM Palette
Liza AM Palette
Temperley Palette
Melody E/S
Night Owl E/S
Riot E/S
Leisuretime E/S (Original & Belle Azur)
De mente e/s
Restrained Rust Lipglass Stain
Ghetto Lipglass Stain
New Years Yves Lipglass
Relay Race L/g
Boy Magnet L/G
Sunray L/G
Turquoise Pigment
Maroon Pigment
Cocoa Beach Pigment
Coco Pigment
Deckchair Pigment
Moxie L/S
Isabella Blow L/S
Strawberry Blonde l/s
Cockatease l/s
Metal Rock MSF
Gold Deposit MSF
Naked You MSF (Original & Mcqueen)
Petticoat MSF
So Ceylon MSF

Stereo Rose MSF(Original release) Had this, but swapped it ages ago)
Pleasureflush (Had this, but swapped it ages ago)