Overall rating: 5
Price: 3
Packaging Quality: 5
Would You Buy This Product Again?: yes!

Comments: i think this a cheaper alternative to black tied. i dont have black tied so i dont know. but clubbing is black with silver glitter. i use it just about every day!! i think its like $3 but its def. worth it!

__________________
"Elegance doesn't mean being noticed, it means being remembered." -Giorgio Armani

http://www.myspace.com/7046107

Overall rating: 5
Price: 2
Packaging Quality: 5
Would You Buy This Product Again?: Oh yeah.


I was worried that the color wouldn't be that pigmented like most of the dark shades I've tried in various other brands (cough: maybelline/covergirl) but it was super pigmented on me. I agree, it's a great alternative to black tied. You can't beat the price, like 2.99 a pot..wish jane had more colors to pick from...

__________________
I like pretty things.

Overall rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 4
Would You Buy This Product Again?: Nope.

I owned this eyeshadow for quite some time and was happy with it, especially for doing smokey eyes. Then I bought Milani's Storm which appears to be an identical color at first...which is why I put off buying Milani Storm for so long. Anyway, I swatched the two side-by-side and Jane's Clubbing doesn't even compare! Storm is much smoother and darker and blends better. I think they both run around $2.99 at drugstores so I would definitely go for Milani Storm over Clubbing.

Overall rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 3
Would You Buy This Product Again?: Doubt it.

I use black eyeshadows almost every day, and I need one that is pigmented and hopefully doesn't smudge or wear off too easily. Jane's Clubbing is a richly pigmented black with relatively noticeable glitter. It's great for smoky eyes since the pigment goes on so well, nice and dark. It's very easy to remove though, which is a bad point for me, since I want my shadows to stay on. Still, not a bad buy, though I probably wouldn't purchase it again.

Overall rating: 3
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 4
Would You Buy This Product Again?: no

had to much glitter and didnt stay on very well
within an hour it started to fade

Overall rating: 3.5
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 3
Would You Buy This Product Again?: if i run out

i like to use this as a crease color and it works quite well actually! it's suppose to be a dupe for black tied too. i used to use it as liner and it dusted my cheeks and it was pretty irritating, so it's permanently just a crease color. the blending gets an A-, and the color payoff gets a B.

Overall rating: 3
Price: 4
Packaging Quality: 4
Would You Buy This Product Again?: yes

Comments: I haven't tried Black tied, but I think this e/s is an affordable dupe. Payoff is so-so; you have to layer and pack it on, and if the glitter pieces were smaller, it would spread better on the skin. But you cannot deny this puppy gives you a smokey eye! Just use it before you apply any face m/u.

__________________
"Out of life's school of war: What does not destroy me, makes me stronger."
~Nietzsche

Overall rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 4
Would You Buy This Product Again?: YES

I love this color so much, I dont have to pack it on or anything. It goes on really well when applied wet and doesnt clump in the pot. My only complaint is LOTS of fallout.

Overall rating: 3
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 4
Would You Buy This Product Again?: Yeah

I liked it for the most part but because i have oily lids i noticed it was fading and on the move within an hour or so. It's great for Smoky eyes though! I wonder if i used Blacktrack as a sort of base then layered Clubbing on top if it would hold out better..

__________________

Rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging: 3
Would you Repurchase? Yeah maybe.

Its good for the purpose it serves, but I dont use black much.

Overall rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would You Buy This Product Again?: I doubt it.

Clubbing looks good in the pot, sure, but I've always had problems with it. There's too much glitter in it for me, and it isn't very easy to blend.

Overall rating: 4
Price: 5
Packaging Quality: 5
Would You Buy This Product Again?: no

i think this color looks really nice in the pot, but honestly, i don't really find myself using this too much.. i'll always choose a matte black over this glittery color.. i think my preference may have to do with the glitters... i just don't have much reason to do looks that calls for black glittery eyeshadow...

i think it's a nice shade to have.. and at $4 a pop it's affordable and not a complete waste of money... as for why i would not buy it again, i think i may want to try out milani's storm as mentioned by drivenbyyourmom