Overall: 4
Price Value: 3
Packaging Quality 5
Buy again? Maybe

This is L'oreal's answer to MAC Fluidlines. Midnight Blue looks like an unbelievably gorgeous "midnight blue" in the pot (which, btw, is very similar to the Fluidlines pot). It comes with its own little angled brush, which really worked quite nicely. The product went on smoothly and without incident. Now, in reality (i.e., after application) the color is a vivid "blurple" and contains very tiny reflects. This is my first blue in this type of liner and I think it'll work well for me. I'll need to wear it a few more times to make a definitive decision about it.

__________________

Overall: 4
Price Value: 3
Packaging Quality 5
Buy again? Not Sure

This is a nice cream liner from L'oreal. The color is a black/blue imo. It also has some shimmer to it but its VERY subtle. i think u only notice the shimmer if ur in really bright light!