your most hated mac e/s?

[Kitsunesunset]

pink venus, lotusland, velvet moss and floral fantasy. ugh.

 

[blueglitter]

got to be idol eyes hate the es so much

 

[shimmercoconut]

i really don't like bright future, vibrant grape, and expensive pink...yet I bought it 2x...go figure

 

[cloudsweare]

French Cuff.

Fall out everywhere.

Also....

Pen n' Pink (I trashed it....seriously, it was that bad)
Black Tied
Vibrant Grape

 

[lmcmullen]

I hate Blackberry. Sheer, dry, chalky, aggravating.

I was lucky enough to read here before I bought a lot of MAC, so I learned from all you ladies to stay away from most lustres....

 

[PrettyGirlDoc]

Another vote here for lime. Disappointing color payoff.

 

[sereagoso]

I really dislike Idol Eyes & Pink Venus... Idol Eyes has too much fall out and not enough payoff, and Pink Venus just makes me look sick

 

[Fiberluver]

oh, and Sushi Flower. It's a very pretty color, but the payoff really sucks eggs.

Agreed!

Sushi flower, Carbon, Shroom are the worse MAC e/s ever!!!

 

[geeko]

Slip pink sucks... makes me eyes looks like I just cried BOOO... such a pity. looks so pretty in the pan.

 

[roop300]

i hate any red or copper colour. makes me look like ive cried!

 

[martiangurll]

Most disappointing--Idol Eyes. Maybe I should try again now I know to use a base and pat it on and I got one used so maybe someone ruined the finish but I swapped that sucker away. So pretty in the pan. So meh on the lids.

Most hated--Ego (the Starflash one, not the Peacocky one) great pigmentation, very blendable, gorgeous mid tone neutral pink, true to pan color, and made my eye look like a bunny rabbit with pink eye. So unattractive I had to swap it. It was a little too blendable, all the fall out irritated the shit out of my eyeballs and then I really had pink eye, not just looking like I had it. Serious bunny rabbit city pink eye.

Runner Up Most Hated--don't excommunicate me or anything but I love the Naked Lunch color but it was a hot shimmery mess on me and looks like total fish scales--emphasized every crepey skin contour and crows foot on my eye.lids I rename it Regurgitated Lunch. Seriously ugly on me which sucks because I love the color, the duochrome, the finish and all that. But I am not trying to look like the CryptKeeper.

 

[Rubiez]

I think anything Lustre sucks...but I may be wrong because ever since I first bought Swimming, I've avoided lustre finishes ever since.

Oh! And MAC's mattes. I've used mattes from Sugarpill and they blend BEAUTIFULLY, but I can never work with mattes from MAC like Newly Minted or Fig 1 >_<

 

[TXBeautyBaby]

Passionate, I hate this e/s!!! Its stiff and has horrible pigmentation.

 

[makeupforever25]

I think the name is Moss (forgive me if I'm wrong). It's a dark green color....I received it as a gift a like 4 years ago and HATE IT! I cannot get it to blend well for the life of me It sits in my collection and never gets used.

 

[lovelyeyes21]

For some reason i really cant stand silver ring

 

[sayah]

Mythology! So beautiful though.

 

[ThePowderPuff]

Satin Taupe! Makes me look like I have been hit in the face.

 

[colormeblue]

I hope nobody gets mad at me for this but i hate forgery...too much fall out and just all around messy for me anyway.

 

[kittenish]

There are eyeshadows I hate just for it's color like Electra, Swish, Tilt, Winkle I also hate when the color is beautiful but the texture sucks BeautyMarked, newly minted, forgery, teal. I have Electric coral pigment from pro which I find pretty lame. I'm also pretty bummed about the color payoff from the prolongwear eyeshadows.

 

[Mac4Megan]

Green smoke- can't get it to show up, just leaves a green glittery tinge to the lids, in a very bad way Violet trance- beautiful vibrant purple in the pan, ZERO color payoff, I even scraped off the top layer, tried using it wet, dig my brush in and get virtually no color. I would just through it in the trash but the color is so pretty I can't part with it.