Carmen is really gorgeous! Actually I like it much more than Annabella. On my lips, it's cool-toned and bright pinky red. It's like a more pigmented version of Dragon girl. It's the red lipstick I found for a long time ago! So Nars, seriously...why did you put it in the exclusives? It should be one of the 30 shades.
And about Catherine, I'm in love with it! It's bright coral and it's like between pinky and orange coral. In other words, It doesn't lean on either pink or orange. I thought it isn't special, but it's more unique than I expected. And it's brighter than Brigitte.
I'm in love with Carmen and Catherine both!