MAC Pencilled In Collection (Feb 5, 2015)

[bulbasaur359]

I love that they added new colors. Looks to be perm as well. I am behind on the thread so forgive me but they are supposed to be perm right? I want some but have to wait for more money lol. I got a couple of lippies from Toledo b/c those won't be around long. I appreciate all the swatches for when I do buy.

 

[thefbomb]

I love that they added new colors. Looks to be perm as well. I am behind on the thread so forgive me but they are supposed to be perm right? I want some but have to wait for more money lol. I got a couple of lippies from Toledo b/c those won't be around long. I appreciate all the swatches for when I do buy.

They are all perm. Although Ive heard heroine may not be!

 

[bulbasaur359]

Thank you @thefbomb I hope Heroine stays. I know so many are after that one. I have the lipstick and love the color. I wonder if I get looks tho lol. Oh well I guess.

 

[MakeupQueen4]

Can't wait for my order to arrive It should be here this Friday. I purchased Edge to Edge, Heroine, Talking Points, and Nightingale. I'll swatch FYH and RW in store tmrw and pick up whichever I like best. I hope my counter has Dervish and Cork in stock as I would really love to pick those up. Geez I have lip pencil fever all of a sudden

 

[kiara22]

Good, Im wanting to have a night pink lip and candy yum yum is the perfect fully matte pink

 

[kaitlynxo]

Can't wait for my order to arrive It should be here this Friday. I purchased Edge to Edge, Heroine, Talking Points, and Nightingale. I'll swatch FYH and RW in store tmrw and pick up whichever I like best. I hope my counter has Dervish and Cork in stock as I would really love to pick those up. Geez I have lip pencil fever all of a sudden

Great choices! Edge to edge and nightingale are my favourites.

 

[retrofox]

Oh man, just ordered all the liners plus Tenor (Oxblood, Opera, and Victoriana are on the way!) SUPER STOKED!!!! I haven't hauled like this in a long time!

 

[thefbomb]

Went in store didn't look at ANY of these lip liners but candy yum yum and ETE. Only bought CYY almost got hip n happy cause I liked it next to snob, at the counter a different girl told me ETE is more versatile and she'd get that because I told her to scrap HNH so I can think of which one I want. So I just left with CYY and that's it. Not bad for a low buy

 

[lyseD]

Went in store didn't look at ANY of these lip liners but candy yum yum and ETE. Only bought CYY almost got hip n happy cause I liked it next to snob, at the counter a different girl told me ETE is more versatile and she'd get that because I told her to scrap HNH so I can think of which one I want. So I just left with CYY and that's it. Not bad for a low buy

Hmm, interesting. I have HNH so do I need ETE?

 

[thefbomb]

Hmm, interesting. I have HNH so do I need ETE?

From what the sales girl/MUA showed me HMH was more pink and ETE was more brown. I didn't try both on me but HNH honestly looked closer in colour to snob than ETE did so that's why I thought of getting HNH. Anther girl described ETE to me as if whirl and soar had a baby, she also told me she'd get ETE over HNH because it's more versatile. To me they looked different enough.

 

[lyseD]

Hmm, interesting. I have HNH so do I need ETE?

From what the sales girl/MUA showed me HMH was more pink and ETE was more brown. I didn't try both on me but HNH honestly looked closer in colour to snob than ETE did so that's why I thought of getting HNH. Anther girl described ETE to me as if whirl and soar had a baby, she also told me she'd get ETE over HNH because it's more versatile. To me they looked different enough.

Thanks. I think I'll check it out tomorrow.

 

[Slimmycakes]

I'm super elated you ladies have confirmed this to be permanent because I want them all! Well, mostly all. I behaved today and only purchased what I would use immediately. I picked up Edge to Edge (better for my NC45 versus Rosy Rim although I may go back to it), Nightingale (similar to beet but different undertones so worth having both) and Follow Your Heart (perfect for all those pinky reds). Ruby Woo is bluer than Cherry so that will eventually come home with me. That's a need. CYY is so bright and perfect for the lippy. Cyber World, Talking Points and Chic Trick are all on my list as well. Slowly but surely.

 

[DMcG9]

Thanks. I think I'll check it out tomorrow.

I have all these pencils and just picked up ETE today so I thought I'd swatch them on myself even though you should check them out in person.
I'm NW20.


Left to Right: HNH, EtE, Soar, Whirl.

 

[Rikers Girl]

[ATTACHMENT=1092]heroine (728k. jpg file)[/ATTACHMENT]

 

[thefbomb]

I have all these pencils and just picked up ETE today so I thought I'd swatch them on myself even though you should check them out in person.
I'm NW20.


Left to Right: HNH, EtE, Soar, Whirl.

Thanks, honestly i like HNH and ETE....Im pretty tempted to get ETE. Not sure what to wear it with though

 

[DMcG9]

Thanks, honestly i like HNH and ETE....Im pretty tempted to get ETE. Not sure what to wear it with though

I tried it on alone this afternoon and like it that way more than I like HNH which looks too pastel for my liking on my lips alone. I think I will try it with Nouvelle Vogue later.

 

[thefbomb]

I tried it on alone this afternoon and like it that way more than I like HNH which looks too pastel for my liking on my lips alone. I think I will try it with Nouvelle Vogue later.

I wonder how it will look with snob which i find light for me

 

[NaomiH]

Stopped by my counter and grabbed Nightingale liner. I think I'll also end up getting RW, ETE,FYH and CW at some point too.

 

[lilinah]

Quote: Originally Posted by lyseD Hmm, interesting. I have HNH so do I need ETE?



They are very different pinks.
H'n'H is a nice light, but not bright, true pink.
EtE is more muted, nuder, & a jot warmer pink. I think EtE is more versatile than H'n'H because it can go pink or go nude, so it will work with a wider range of lip products.

I tested it and almost picked it up today, but i'd gotten enough stuff - i'm probably order it from the website.

Today i bought Cyber World, Heroine, and Nightingale pencils. Yeah, yeah, i already have one H pencil, but someone here was saying how well these work as a lip color all by themselves, so i thought it might be good to have an extra one to travel with for the summer.

 

[lyseD]

Quote: Originally Posted by lyseD Hmm, interesting. I have HNH so do I need ETE?



They are very different pinks.
H'n'H is a nice light, but not bright, true pink.
EtE is more muted, nuder, & a jot warmer pink. I think EtE is more versatile than H'n'H because it can go pink or go nude, so it will work with a wider range of lip products.

I tested it and almost picked it up today, but i'd gotten enough stuff - i'm probably order it from the website.

Today i bought Cyber World, Heroine, and Nightingale pencils. Yeah, yeah, i already have one H pencil, but someone here was saying how well these work as a lip color all by themselves, so i thought it might be good to have an extra one to travel with for the summer.

Thanks so much, ETE is back on my list.