MAC Enchanted Eve / Magic Of The Night / Irresistibly Charming Holiday Collection (Oct 18, 2015)

laurennnxox

Well-known member
Question for ya'll, I'm trying to decide between Tonight's The Night and Moon Is Blue. I have the UD Spectrum Palette and Evidence seems pretty similar. Here's T's side by side comparisons. If it was you, would you then skip Moon is Blue?

 

jaymuse

Well-known member
Question for ya'll, I'm trying to decide between Tonight's The Night and Moon Is Blue. I have the UD Spectrum Palette and Evidence seems pretty similar. Here's T's side by side comparisons. If it was you, would you then skip Moon is Blue?

Hmmm I'd skip it! But I guessed it would be based off how often you wear blue eyeshadow because I imagine the formula and color to be about the same.
 

Vandekamp

Well-known member
Question for ya'll, I'm trying to decide between Tonight's The Night and Moon Is Blue. I have the UD Spectrum Palette and Evidence seems pretty similar. Here's T's side by side comparisons. If it was you, would you then skip Moon is Blue?

The Moon is Blue looks more vibrant and pigmented. I would get it. However, they look almost identical. If you are trying to save money or avoid duplication you can skip it.
 

Marsha Pomells

Well-known member
Well, I won't be stalking with you guys. But I can help with some stalking motivational material...
1c18fd86_image.jpeg
I don't know which rugby team he plays for... But yeah...
 

Corally

Well-known member
  Question for ya'll, I'm trying to decide between Tonight's The Night and Moon Is Blue. I have the UD Spectrum Palette and Evidence seems pretty similar. Here's T's side by side comparisons. If it was you, would you then skip Moon is Blue?
Hmmm I'd skip it! But I guessed it would be based off how often you wear blue eyeshadow because I imagine the formula and color to be about the same.
I agree. I don't really wear blue eyeshadow so I'd skip MIB with ease if I had Evidence.
 

GreenEyedAllie

Well-known member
Question for ya'll, I'm trying to decide between Tonight's The Night and Moon Is Blue. I have the UD Spectrum Palette and Evidence seems pretty similar. Here's T's side by side comparisons. If it was you, would you then skip Moon is Blue?
Personally, I'd skip. At the very least, wait to test it at a counter to see if difference in formula is :love:
 

bluelitzer

Well-known member
I love The Moon Is Blue but I already have stuff that could look similar... (Freshwater+Royal Wink underneath) VERY tempted to still get it though!!! :)) if it's still available in December, I will get it. I so, so love this kind of blue+smokey eye look. It was my signature special holiday look last year.
 

laurennnxox

Well-known member
The Moon is Blue looks more vibrant and pigmented. I would get it. However, they look almost identical. If you are trying to save money or avoid duplication you can skip it.

Quote: Originally Posted by Corally


I agree. I don't really wear blue eyeshadow so I'd skip MIS with ease if I had Evidence.

Hmm, yeah. I don't wear blue that much. I just love how vibrant it looks. I wish I could see how it applied and blended on the lid. T just has a microscopic dot on her eyelid of this shade. I love evidence, I feel like it has the tendecy to blend out pretty dark though. It takes some packing on to keep that vibrancy.
 

laurennnxox

Well-known member
Personally, I'd skip. At the very least, wait to test it at a counter to see if difference in formula is
love.gif
Yeah, I might do that! I have court this thursday as part of work and we usually get out around 4 and we get to go home when it's over. The mall is less than 5 minutes away from the courthouse. I might swing by and swatch the shadows in store. I'd hope they'd have stock to at least last the day. I only have a small mac counter inside dillards.
 

BellaInPink

Well-known member
Im so exhausted. ..ive been checking every hour since 3 a.m. not to mention yesterday getting up at 6 a.m. for something else and going to bed at 12 midnight. Just really trying to avoid going in store the day of release
 

BrittLuvsMakeup

Well-known member
I will grab one of each and i can return one later if I need to.

I think that's a good idea. I would deeply regret if I didn't purchase Shaft of Gold only to wish I would have grabbed it later on. Like you said, you can always return something if you no longer want it. Plus, the latest swatch of it posted in this thread made me want it again, lol. So my list is back to Evening Rendezvous, Oh Darling, and Shaft of Gold.


Quote: Originally Posted by BellaInPink

Im so exhausted. ..ive been checking every hour since 3 a.m. not to mention yesterday getting up at 6 a.m. for something else and going to bed at 12 midnight. Just really trying to avoid going in store the day of release
I've been checking every hour since 4 this morning and I'm tired too so I know how you feel. I personally wish they would just give us a specific time rather than having to check the site all day. I understand that that may mean that web traffic may increase if everyone came on the site at the same time but at least we wouldn't feel like we had to be glued to my computer, tablet, or phone screen all day trying to see when it's going to launch.
 

BellaInPink

Well-known member
I think that's a good idea. I would deeply regret if I didn't purchase Shaft of Gold only to wish I would have grabbed it later on. Like you said, you can always return something if you no longer want it. Plus, the latest swatch of it posted in this thread made me want it again, lol. So my list is back to Evening Rendezvous, Oh Darling, and Shaft of Gold.  I've been checking every hour since 4 this morning and I'm tired too so I know how you feel. I personally wish they would just give us a specific time rather than having to check the site all day. I understand that that may mean that web traffic may increase if everyone came on the site at the same time but at least we wouldn't feel like we had to be glued to my computer, tablet, or phone screen all day trying to see when it's going to launch.
You're so right. I personally have never had any problem ordering from Dose of Colors or Jeffree Star sites when they release on a set time and day... then again they're not brands that are so well known by many. One thing is certain, the minute it launches, im going to sleep good lol
 

Ana A

Well-known member
I was hoping we'll have an early morning release since I work all day today and I can't have my phone out but it seems like Nordies will have to do tomorrow morning. :/
 
Top