How about breaking up a gift set? Sephora has many to choose from. I love masks so I would recommend the PTR Just Mask It set for $25. It has 3 masks: http://www.sephora.com/just-mask-it-P402690?skuId=1747542
Or the Josie Maran body cream trio for $25: http://www.sephora.com/whimsical-wonder-whipped-argan-oil-body-butter-trio-P401752?skuId=1756220 (who doesn't need lotion at there desk??)
This Tory Burch duo for $18 is also cute: http://www.sephora.com/tory-burch-mini-duo-P400568?skuId=1744960
You can also try a lip set like the Bite Rewind set for $25 and that'll be 4 items: http://www.sephora.com/best-bite-rewind-P401615?keyword=BITE%20BEAUTY%20Best%20Bite%20Rewind%20P401615&skuId=1751262&_requestid=503160
I say browse through the gift section as they have so many cute little gifts sets that can be separated for our gift grab. That way I can stop bombarding you with links.