Just as I planned....
I'll compile a list, lol. But for starters, I think you should get all of the new Anastasia Beverly Hills releases. They are not currently at Sephora yet but they will be soon. You need the Sundipped Glow Kit as I think it was made with WOC in mind, the Modern Renaissance Eyeshadow Palette because of the color selection, and the Summer Lip Gloss set (which unfortunately, is only exclusive to ABH's website).
I've noticed the same thing and have been shaking my head, lol. Sephora seriously needs to sift through all of these reviews and delete these bogus comments because they are difficult to wade through if you are looking for real reviews. I can't say I'm surprised this happened, I bet these same people are the ones who did this when Champagne Pop first came out too. They treat the review section like a forum.
I'm so sorry to hear that you didn't receive your order. Your order should have definitely been delivered today since you ordered before the cutoff time for 1 day shipping and paid for the upgrade. Customer service should have refunded you without question and it was very unprofessional for them to treat you rudely when you had a valid complaint (even if you didn't, they still shouldn't have treated you rudely). I don't think you should settle for anything less than a refund because technically, your order is most likely going to arrive on Tuesday, which is the same time VIB Rouges whose orders were shipped yesterday will get theirs with free flash 2-day shipping. I think you should keep calling until this is settled to your satisfaction.