Man, over here, we take back everything. We almost never say no.
But, I did refuse a return the other day (there was no receipt). A lady came in with a busted Studio Fix saying that she had just bought it and it "broke". The compact was pretty dirty. I opened the compact and the powder was crumbled, but it didn't look like the whole amount to me. So, I checked out the batch code in the back and it had been made early in 2005. There is no way a Studio Fix would have been sitting around at our counter for that long. So I told her that I can tell when the compact was made and that I can't, unfortunately take it back.
About the LE items, that's ridiculous. I have never heard that before.
This is a pet peeve of mine, but I kinda get annoyed when people say "It's not used" or "I didn't even open it" because it doesn't make a difference. If you walk away with it and bring it back, out it goes. There is a girl who comes to our counter every other day and buys and returns, buys and returns, buys and returns...grrrr.
It's not fair that MAC doesn't have a return policy in Europe. I think the return policy in North America is so customer friendly because of the high level of competition between markets. There is so much here to choose from that you have to have an incentive to keep customers coming back to your company. That's just the standard here, so most companies have to follow it.