I actually found the opposite.... too chalky-looking when I used my fingers. What I do is dispense a *very small* amount of paint onto the back of my hand, lay my 242 brush onto it, and press it down and wiggle a little to "melt" the paint onto my brush (the heat of my hand warms it up perfectly so it doesn't ball up). Then I apply it to my eyelid using short, quick strokes. I find that gets me the most even and blended finish. I also hear 217 is great for paints - natural bristles as opposed to 242's synthetic (but 242 works great for me so I'll stick with it).
The very first time I used Bare Canvas with a brush, I squeezed out a little too much product and tried to use it all up, not wanting to be wasteful - that's when it looked really chalky and thick and splotchy - maybe that's what happened to you, too... who knows? If you start with a really small amount, you can always add to it, which is obviously much easier than trying to undo overapplication. Anyway, it's another thing to consider. HTH!!