Re: I need to choose 4 N collection shadow colours for a palette. Which should I choo
I bought/love: Neutral Pink, Modest Tone, Nanogold, and Remotely Grey.
Modest Tone is the prettiest neutral lid shade I've ever seen, and Remotely Grey and Neutral Pink are fantastic. Nanogold is the least cohesive of the collection, so maybe you'd be better off getting Dark Edge for your palette. Nanogold doesn't have much to add to a smokey look or an everyday look, it's just a cool, unique color to play with every now and then.
BTW, I'm pretty close to your coloring, NC15.