I recently tried Rimmel Vinyl Stars and it's actually not too bad. Yummy smell and the colours were quite pigmented on my lips, but sadly, they faded within 15 minutes.
I really love Neautrogena's glossed, in the box tube with a sponge brush. I have a few and they feel amazing! Glam is my absolute favorite! It's a sheer pink coral color, so freakin' pretty!!
With Milani I know their crystal gloss in the shade whisper is just like MACs C-thru. I kinda like it better because its not all sticky. My favorite Milani gloss is called tres pink. its a bright pink, but its beautiful. i get compliments on it everywhere.