I liked/bought Lily White the best (I don't own Vanilla & I have never seen it IRL). I really liked Apricot Pink too and might go back. I mixed these two together on the back of my hand at the store & it was really pretty!
I like the colors of all three. Unfortunately, Pinked Mauve and my eyes don't get along.
I am afraid to wear Apricot Pink until I find out there is no red dye that will cause a reaction. I am sure I will love Lily White when I am not wearing Vanilla.