Blackest of Black Liquid Eyeliner

[Indian Barbie]

I use bodyshop but it's not quite black enough. I want one thats really dark and really long lasting.

I have tried mac liquidlast but i feel like its a waste sometimes cos it dries up and goes gloopy after 2 months

anybody got recs? fankoo xx

 

[kaexbabey]

i really like almay liquid eyeliner. the one with the white wand. blacktrack doesnt stay on me but this does.

 

[user79]

I was watching some Youtube videos on this earlier comparing different liquid eyeliners, and a few videos rated the Revlon Colorstay liquid eyeliner very highly. So I went out and bought it today! Haven't used it yet but I tested it on my hand, it's very black and the top applicator seems really good, and the lasting power as well. I'll get back to you on this once I've used it on my eyes.

 

[ZoZo]

Give a try to NYC liquid liner in (Jet Black 860), I know it is cheap brand but I liked it more than other high brand which I bought.

 

[rachybloom]

It's pricey but Chanel's liquid eyeliner pen is pretty fantastic. I bought it for a cat-eye look I did for prom and it didn't move ALL night.. even through sweaty-dancing and even sleeping. It's pretty dark too.. I just applied it very slowly so it evenly dispersed on my skin and it was very very black.

 

[Amaranth]

L'Oreal makes one with Carbon in it, so you get this really nice, ultra-black matte look. It's possibly called Lineur Intense...but I'm not 100% on that. I JUST finished mine and threw it out, otherwise I'd go check for you. GOSH also makes a really nice matte black liquid eyeliner...if you can find it anywhere. I love that line, it's like my MAC substitute since I can't get it where I am right now

Of course, those are both non-waterproof (the GOSH one isn't, anyway...as previously mentioned, can't really check the L'Oreal one). But they don't move on me and last throughout the day...as long as I don't go swimming.

 

[Amaranth]

OH WAIT NO! I just Googled it, and this is the L'Oreal one I was thinking of:

Buy L'Oreal Carbon Black Telescopic Precision Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black 835 Online at drugstore.com

It came free with my mascara but I was confused because why would eyeliner be called "Telescopic"?

 

[ndn-ista]

L'oreal HIP - hands down

 

[kelcia]

I'm indian and i'm very into black eyeliner. Kajal like.
If you don't like the MAC stuff which i agree gets goopy but it stays on forever then you should go with the L'Oreal Hip liner. It's not liquid it's gel in a pot but with a better eyeliner brush (it comes with one I actually use a paint brush that i got for 2 bucks) it's amazing. Ridiculously dark and long lasting. AND you can use it on your bottom waterline! I could never do that with liquid get it all up in my eye. Not cool.

 

[Kuuipo]

My two darkest are NARS eyeliner and Wet and Wild-esp. the waterproof variety.

 

[Sexya(TM)?Princess]

makeupforever waterproof liquidliner

it looks like the most perfect smooth inky black line and it will last thru anything.

 

[M.A.C. head.]

The Wet 'n' Wild H20 proof liquid liner is VERY black and applies very clean.

It's like $1.99 too.

 

[nunu]

Collection 2000 got a great black liquid eyeliner.

 

[user79]

I am really liking the Revlon one, the applicator is like a felt pen tip which I find more convenient than the brush kind. It is really black! And stays very well, dries on your eyes really fast. I was going to get a new Blacktrack fluidline but I find this Revlon one easier to apply!

 

[GlamYOURUs]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZoZo Give a try to NYC liquid liner in (Jet Black 860), I know it is cheap brand but I liked it more than other high brand which I bought.

Yup! Thats the one I have and it was only 2 bucks. lol Its really dark and it stays on all day/night. I love it! I don't even reach for my blacktrack anymore.

 

[jbid]

inglot liquid eyeliner with felt tip applicatior is a real black black. it's so intense i have to be really careful.

 

[xsnowwhite]

i use prestige black liquid liner and it stays on alot even if I cry or something.

 

[CoConutNwuT]

Quote:

Originally Posted by kaexbabey i really like almay liquid eyeliner. the one with the white wand. blacktrack doesnt stay on me but this does.

I 2nd this! i have fallen asleep with it on before and woke up with it still in place on those drunken nights! lol!! its really good though! i have been using this stuff for years and years! and i love it!

 

[Temptasia]

Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner in Blackest Black.

The tip gives you a lot of control and precision and it stays put all day. If you like to wing it out...this is a must.

My gfs are always amazed at how quickly I can line my eyes with liquid liner.

I also like how it does not get goopy and the perfect amount is on the brush each time. I never have to dip more than twice per eye unless it's getting to the bottom of the bottle.

 

[lara]

The Rimmel one with a felt-tip applicator. It's a real blue-black and wears really well.