Originally Posted by FullWroth
To be fair, the awesome people here on Specktra aren't given challenges and expected to execute them right away with no opportunity to do research or really sit down and plan it out, and I don't know if the contestants are given any time to consult with their models about their skin types, allergies, etc. beforehand or if they have to take it out of their hour of make-up time, whereas we all work on our faces and those of friends and family when posting stuff, so it's a face/skin we're familiar with from the get-go.
Usually when we have challenges here, everyone gets a chance to look up reference pictures, think about the look they want, maybe sketch it out beforehand, and they get several passes at it. After all, nobody knows what you did until you post those final photos. And other incredibly talented people on here post stuff they had in a flash of inspiration, not on demand.
It's hard to have inspiration on demand, especially if (like that one girl) you don't really understand the look you're supposed to be going for and can't just go online and do a quick Google search for disco style. Add into that the pressure of having no contact with the outside world, having to live with a bunch of strangers all of a sudden in a new environment, cameras following you around everywhere all day and night, having very little time to sit down and relax because the minute the shooting ends the director pulls everyone out one by one for interviews and nobody can go to bed until they're over, the competition, the prize, initial jet lag, wanting to look good on TV...
Also, try to imagine that you're standing there working on your model, and there's a camera guy, sometimes more than one, just hovering around you, poking the camera in to get close-ups, asking you to change sides so s/he can get a better shot, etc. Then, when they finally lay off, one of the judges comes in to check out your work and give you some feedback, and of course even if their feedback is really good, now you have barely any time to fix it. Then they go on to the next person, after doing 500 takes of talking to you, and the camera guy's all up in your face again. Even the best, most ninja-style camera operator is still a very visible "looking over your shoulder" presence that HAS to affect one's nerves.
I do think the work on the disco challenge was sub-par, but at the same time, I think even some of our best Specktra guys and girls would break under the pressure and immediacy of a "here's your challenge DO IT NOW" process given all those factors. I hope their level of artistry goes up as they all get more comfortable in their new environment and get used to the cameras, though. I wouldn't blame them if it didn't, I'd just get bored and not watch the show.
I don't think they should expect the MUAs to decide how to style their models' hair though, unless it's some kind of full-body/full-head challenge where you have to extend the make-up up into the hair. They're not hair stylists, they shouldn't be judged on whether the hair matches the make-up/challenge. That should be for a hair stylist to deal with, as it probably would be in a real-world situation (not that some MUAs don't also do hair, but not all of them do) where you hire separate hair and make-up people.
|