Clinique brush on Cream Liner - True Black

[vica]

has anyone tried this product?

ive browsed on makeupalley and a majority of the people said that this one is alot blacker than MaC's F/L and it lasts longer BUTTT i wanna know your guys' opinions !!
Oh yea and since i am on a very very limited budget (meaning, i only have 20 bucks

LOL) has anyone tried the L'oreal Hip cream liner?? Im lookin for something that is the blackest black, that will me a long time, and is worth the price...

if anyone has swatches comparing clinique and mac and hip , please share!

 

[lara]

I've tried the Clinique liner and I found it to be a little hard and dry. The colour payoff was good (with a bit of elbow grease), but I couldn't say that it's a blacker-black than Blacktrack.

 

[VioletB]

I was snooping in Clinique the other day at work and wasn't too impressed. I think blacktrack fluidline is better. The color smudged off my hand even after it dried.