comparison!!

[MAC is love]

which one is better IYO, select cover up...or select moisturecover? i currently own the select moisturecover concealer...and i'm considering getting a different one just to try it, but i would hate to buy it and then totally dislike it. thoughts? opinions? TIA!

 

[DaizyDeath]

ive heard from alot of people that they hate macs concelors. I have select cover up and i really dislike it, it seems to make the area that i put it on look dry and flakey and doesnt conceal enough.

 

[f1rewater]

Ditto on the Select Cover-Up dislike. I use it to cover undereye circles and i find it hard to blend, drying and it settles into the few lines i have under my eyes.

 

[BlahWah]

I have moisturecover and I find that it looks a bit dry on me, even tho it's supposed to be more moisturizing. I swapped for Studio Lights in Sand and have used that for my undereye circles. I've liked that much better both for shade (peachiness cancels out the darkness better) and texture - it's more moist so I can apply 2 thin layers without having things cake up on me. So in short... neither. =T Tho if my skin starts to act up I may try select cover up. Moisturecover doesn't stay long on me.

 

[redambition]

i find select cover up is much better under the eyes than select moisturecover is.

out of the two, select cover up is the better one

 

[prinzessin784]

I like Select Coverup! I have wicked bag circles but on days when they're not quite so bad I can cover them with a combination of Select Coverup, Select SPF foundation, and Bare Minerals. It takes a lot of layering but it works better that way and it lasts longer for me.

 

[glittergoddess27]

I have the studio stick, Studio finish, and the moisturecover and like all of these better than the coverup. Once applied I thought the cover up looked chalky on me no matter what and rarely stayed put. I use the moisturecover daily and have never had a problem with it, but I always moisturize and spritz my face with Fix+ in the am before applying. I like the studio finish for my hella dark circles,.. it can be sheered with moisturizer and built up if needed,.. and the stick is good for on the go touch ups,..I like almost everything but the cover up.

 

[MAC is love]

thanks! yeah i really like my moisturecover, i was just seeing what else is out there that might be good

 

[MAC_Whore]

I have a rave for Select Cover Up. I love it under the eyes and from lash to brow as a base.

Moisturecover is really moisturizing. My skin is normal, so it is too emollient for me. Moisturecover is THE product for under the eyes for people who have dry skin, IMO.