Concealer Colour for Asian skin with BLACK circles?

[noyb]

what colour would you recommend for the concealer for a girl who is a pakistani/asian? and has really dark (black NOT blue) circles... she uses ysl number 2 but it makes her bags look grey even when she patts it in instead of rubbing it....?? i kno yellow wud be for fair skin... her skin colour is kinda browny/yellowy... lolz.. plz help.

 

[Kiseki]

That happens with the YSL pen because it's too sheer for the amount of coverage she needs, here are my suggestions:

Clé de Peau Concealer (one of the most pigmented concealers I've used), Laura Mercier's Secret Camouflage (heavily pigmented, but you need to mix the concealer with some eye cream to use it on the under eye area) or if you don't like the mix part of it, the Secret Concealer Bobbi Brown's Corrector and/or Creamy Concealer.

The best for her is to get matched at a counter or store, while we may have an idea of what color suits her best, none of us can say that "color X would work great for her".

And, there's always Dermablend.