Mine are fluid, but really thick, if that makes sense. They don't seem dried up, just really thick. I bought them a year ago and they're the same consistency as they were then, but I find them REALLY hard to apply.
I have Inky, Point Black and Coco Bar.
Anyway, UPDATE: I put some of the Liquidlast Point Black onto the inner lid of a sample jar, and a very small drop of generic eye drops next to it. I took the brush I use for applying creme liner (angled one from CS) and mixed some eye drops into the liner.
Eyedrops worked perfectly to dilute the Liquidlast. It was much thinner, and it looks more like swatches of Fluidline that I've seen. I put it on the back of my hand and let it dry, then applied more over it; it didn't remove the stuff already there.
It dried a lot faster than usual. When it was dry, I rubbed it --- no smearing or flaking. Then I rubbed harder. Then I made it wet and rubbed. Then I rubbed it with wet fingers. It's not coming off. Tomorrow I'll try it on my eyes (I've already got eye makeup on, and I'm soon going to bed, so the last thing I wanted was to apply eyeliner that lasts forever just to have to take it off...)
DO NOT PUT THE DROPS IN YOUR LIQUIDLAST. I don't know what kind of effects that would have long-term. Thx!
I'm going to let it sit, then do the same thing in a bit. Will report back.