do i need these MAC eyeshadows? -updated

[msgraveyard]

heres a list of what i want:

-shimmermoss
-swimming
-humid
-stars n rockets
-parfait amour
-creme de violet
-hepcat
-freshwater
-aquadisiac
-jewel blue
-gorgeous gold
-rule/orange

pigments:
-bright fuchsia
-acid orange
-pinked mauve
-violet/grape (either)

-waterbase mixing medium

-beig-ing shadestick
-silverbleu shadestick
- (one of the pink shadestick, i dont know which one to choose)

these are the colors i already have:

MAC
-bitter
-electric eel
-shroom
-sable
-trax

UD
-gash
-oil slick
-vert
-acid rain
-asphyxia
-X
-baked
-midnight cowboy rides again

Jane
-goldie looks
-twillight zone

what should i take off my list? thanks!!!

 

[Classic Beauty]

Take off humid, and you need either rule or orange. They both are pretty similar.

 

[bellaetoile]

even though they're different colors, i wouldn't get both shimmermoss and aquadisiac. aquadisiac is harder to work with, imo, and shimmermoss has a much better texture. humid and swimming, again, though similar, probably not necessary to have both. stars n rockets is the best color ever, purley because i've never seen anything like it before..

 

[Nick]

I second both of the above recs, except that I do like Humid. I'd skip Rule (nice shadow, but Orange is brighter) and Aquadisiac (Lustre vs Veluxe Pearl, no contest).

 

[bottleblack]

Unless you're accustomed to working with dark shadows, you don't need Humid - I have it and have only worn it once and looked like I got punched in the eye!

 

[lianna]

Freshwater and Gorgeous Gold are must haves. I quite like Humid actually but it is quite a dark green so I suppose it'll depend on your individual preference.

I don't think you'll need a full size of Pinked Mauve though as it doesn't really apply well so I find it hard to get it to look like it does in the pot.