Do I need Wishful when I have Shroom and Naked Lunch?

[Miss_Behave]

is wishful similar to these? *please say yes*

 

[Isis]

I'd have to say yes. I know I passed over that one myself and I also have Shroom & Naked Lunch.

 

[Jennifer Mcfly]

I second...it's too similar that you don't really *need* it

 

[Hikaru-chan]

I have to dissagre because on me Wishful looks quite different from Shroom and Naked Lunch but it may just be my skintone.
Try and test it at a store so you can compare shades.

 

[User34]

they are pretty similiar but I got all three anyway =) hehe.

 

[midnightlouise]

Well you don't really *need* it if you have the others. It's a pretty enough highlighter & looks different on me than either NL or Shroom, but it's not something I'd kick myself for later if I didn't get it.