Dupe for MAC Shade Fluidline?

[MULover1]

This was DC'ed several years ago & my pot finally dried up last month. I have no been able to revive it. Any recommendations for a dupe?

 

[shellygrrl]

Stila Stay All Day Liquid e/l pen in Moss http://www.sephora.com/stay-all-day-waterproof-liquid-eye-liner-P253818?skuId=1221084 Inglot Gel Liner #86 (it may be a little lighter; you could mix it with a black to darken it some) http://www.beautylish.com/s/inglot-cosmetics-matte-collection-amc-eyeliner-gel-86 There were others that were similar in colour but had a shimmer finish, and I'm thinking you'd prefer a matte one.