Eye Shadow Help (long)

[Classic Beauty]

I am so sorry that this is so long. Thanks so mucho in advance!

I made a list of eyeshadows I want,
1. Are any of these similar to each other so that it would be a waste to buy both?
2. Are any of these not worth buying because they just suck?
3. Are there Milani equivalents to any of these?
4. Do you reccommend any other colors?
5. In case you were wondering, I have woodwinked, goldbit, greensmoke, pink venus, trax, and steamy. I also have the inventive eyes quad.

Orange/Peach/Copper Colors
Say, Yeah!*
Casino*
Coppering

Yellow/Gold Colors
Chrome Yellow
Gorgeous Gold
Goldmine

Green Colors
Swimming
Bitter
Humid
Sumptuous Olive
Shimmermoss
Surreal
Silly Goose*

Grey Colors
Carbon
White Frost
Electra
Knight Devine
Crystal Avalanche

Neutral Colors
Shroom
Oceanique*
Nylon
Retrospeckt
Phloof!
Dazzlelight
Naked Lunch

Pink Colors
Sushi Flower
Pink Freeze
Living Pink*
Da Bling
Expensive Pink

Brown Colors
Mulch
Soba
Rummy*
Patina
Amberlight
Tempting
All That Glitters
Falling Star
Twinks

Blue/Teal Colors
Fade
Electric Eel
Tilt
Freshwater
Deep Truth
Flash Track
Moon's Reflection
Zonk Bleu
Aquadisiac

Purple Colors
Idol Eyes
Parfait Amour
Beautiful Iris
Plum Dressing
Hepcat
Star Violet
Crystal
Satellite Dreams
Stars N Rockets
Nocturnelle
Au Contraire*

* denotes limited.

 

[Jude]

Orange/Peach/Copper Colors
Casino* this is MEH. Amber Lights has a much better texture.

Coppering: Must have. Gorgeous crease color.

Yellow/Gold Colors
Chrome Yellow: Hard to work with and gets muddy easily. A lot of people love it though but I cant get it to work.

Gorgeous Gold: Gold with a greenish tinge to it. I don't like the pigmentation on it.

Goldmine: Very pretty color. I love this one.

Green Colors
Swimming: Awesome staple color. Texture is a Lustre which is kinda unfortunate but the color makes up for the texture.

Bitter: Another hard to blend color that just sits in my pallete.

Humid: Hot burning love! This is a color that every girl should have. Awesome for smokey looks and as a crease color.

Sumptuous Olive: Beautiful color. I love this shadow. Another staple for me.

Shimmermoss: Gorgeous color and awesome texture. Looks so pretty with purples.

Grey Colors

Carbon: I hate Carbon. It is so hard to work with and it gets a hard coating on it after use. I would just get a container of Onyx by Bare Escentuals. It is a loose shadow with a deep flat black color and it goes on super velvety.

Electra: Great silver color. My favorite one next to Platinum Pigment.

Knight Devine: So hot. Charcoal gray with bluish undertones and it is a VP. Yessssss.

Crystal Avalanche: Great Highlighting color. One of the standouts in Idol Eyes.

Neutral Colors
Shroom: Staple must-have color, for sure.

Oceanique*: This might be hard to get but it is absolutely stunning.

Nylon: Decent Hilighter. I prefer White Wheat though.

Retrospeckt: Ugh, so hard to work with.

Dazzlelight; A definate must-have.

Naked Lunch: Staple color for anypnes pallete.

I don't do pinks :/

Mulch: Gotta have as a crease and outer eye color.

Soba: Perfect for a neutral eye.

Rummy*: Might be hard to find. Nothing special. Just a brown color.

Patina: I cant figure this one out yet.

Amberlight: A definate yes.

Tempting: Another staple color for every girl.

All That Glitters. Gorrrrgeous.

I am getting lazy now so I am going to give my ratings out of 5..haha. one the lowest of course.

Tilt-3. Pretty but I never grab for it.

Freshwater: 5. amazing!

Deep Truth:5+++++++. This is my favorite shadow color.

Flash Track:4: Too close to Deep truth to be a 5

Moon's Reflection: 3 Too light for me but it depends on your tastes. Great Texture.

Zonk Bleu: very much like Aquadisiac and Steamy. I would get either/or before this.

Aquadisiac: see above.

Purple Colors
Idol Eyes; I cant deal with t his. So chunky and weird for me.

Parfait Amour: Gorgeous and complex purple. Must have.

Beautiful Iris: No need to get this if you have Parfait Amour.

Sattelite Dreams: Great purple color that is good to have if you cant get your hands on Au Contraire.

Nocturnelle: Great color for crease and outer eye.

Au Contraire*; If you can get this, get it. get one or two or three if you can. I use this alot and it is a total staple.

 

[Classic Beauty]

Thanks! That was like more than I expected, DopeSickGirl!

I could love you.

Would anyone like to add on? Please?

Say, Yeah!*
Plum Dressing
Hepcat
Star Violet
Crystal
Fade
Electric Eel
Falling Star
Twinks
Sushi Flower
Pink Freeze
Living Pink*
Da Bling
Expensive Pink
Phloof!
White Frost
Surreal
Silly Goose*

^Need an op still, por favor.

 

[pumpkincat210]

Say, Yeah!*- 4 This color is awesome! And its a veluxe pearl.
Star Violet 5 I love this one-its another Veluxe pearl
Crystal-2 eh, alot of people like this one, but its not my favorite.
Twinks-Brownish color-Veluxe Pearl, I like other browns better though.
Sushi Flower-Too orange-y for my taste. Also couldn't get it to show up like paradisco.
Living Pink*-I like this one, its very bright.
Da Bling-nice light pink.
Expensive Pink-Looks great with Swish
Phloof!-Good hightlighting color..
Surreal-Beautiful Green blue color, not too dark. If you want darker but basically the same is Steamy

 

[glittergoddess27]

Say, Yeah!* - Love this one and it is a veluxe pearl,.. it is very close to Melon pigment though a little less gold tinted,..and also close to Paradisco but shinier,...I would buy this one again,...

Sushi Flower- Suprisingly a favorite of mine,.. though it is not a VP and is kinda matte it blends well,..I use it with everything,....I think the only matte shadow I couldn't live without,..great pigmentation,...

Expensive Pink-The HG of pinks??...VP,...a deep velvety dark pink. I couldn't get it in pro pan because it kept selling out and I couldnt wait for it to be shipped so I bought a pot and depotted. I hug it and kiss it and call it George. If they ever even rumor discontinuing this I will buy at least 20 backups,....

 

[tracie]

just wanted to tell you that plum dressing and hepcat look pretty similar, shimmermoss is great, I'd get that one over surreal (they look somewhat similar in the pot).

I also agree with say yeah! and living pink.

Naked lunch is great too

Swish is also a great pink to add to your list.

 

[user4]

Say, Yeah!*- LOVE THIS COLOR... REALLY SUBTLE AND PRETTY
Sushi Flower- PRETTY PINK... BUT I DONT USE IT TOO MUCH
Living Pink*-ALSO PRETTY, BUT I GUESS IM JUST NOT BIG ON PINK
Expensive Pink-THIS IS THE ONLY PINK I LIKE... ITS BEAUTIFUL
Silly Goose*-I JUST GOT IT... ITS OK BUT FOR SOME REASON IT NEVER SHOWS UP ON ME AS ANYTHING