I know just what you mean! I have a few that are not MAC and they seem to work a bit better. I had my brother draw one of me for me. You might want to see about getting one that easier to use. That MAC one freaks me out!
Here are a few that I have found on MUA that work a bit better.
#1
#2
#3
#4
Also next time you are at a counter (any counter) ask if they have any face charts that blank. Sometimes they will be willing to part with one.
If you print them out try using recycle paper or something with texture to help grab the colors.