Freckletone versus Moderne?

[swaly]

I want both, but not if they're super-similar! It's hard to tell with MAC swatches, so can someone tell me if they're different, and if so, how? (In terms of color, formula, glitteriness, etc.) I'd appreciate it greatly.

 

[ette]

Freckletone is much lighter.

 

[mspixieears]

Moderne is lustre, from a picture, it looks like Freckletone is frostier, and peachier. Moderne is sort of orange-ish, it's hard to explain.

 

[turtlefart]

I've heard that Moderne is a lot lighter than Freckletone. Freckletone was my first MAC lipstick ever, and it will forever have a special place in my heart.

Freckletone is a lustre, but it's not as sheer as some other lustres. It's creamy, with zero glitter and zero frost. It's literally like a medium (if you're pale like I am) creamy layer of peachy lite-caramel.