I am very late to the party, but I just gave in to Guerlain's Rouge Automatique in the shade 160 Bal de Mai. It's a perfect every day shade that gives a bit of life to your face, although it doesn't look as bright on me as it does in Temptalia's swatch. I suppose that's because my lips have more pigmentation. Also, the texture of RA is absolutely perfect! This RA is definitely a splurge, and it's one I was more willing to take. I really admire every swatch I see of all the different Rouge G's, but until Sephora has a F&F sale, or I get a gift card, I'll have to stay away from those.
Katred, I read your blog post and they should hire you to model RA, ha. The photo of you in cherry blossom completely sold me. My complexion is very similar to yours and I was worried that Cherry Blossom would be too frosty and over the top, but it looks perfectly natural on you.
As far as the new Guerlain holiday collection goes, I cannot wait until someone posts swatches of Flirt d'un Jour!