I picked "Other" I think Select Tint, even though it is a tinted moistuizer, conceals redness and gives a fresh look, if you do not apply powder afterwards!
I think it depends on how oily your skin is to begin with. I'm rather oily, so MSF Natural is buildable enough to do some covering for me (I have some acne discoloration to cover but no redness) while leaving me looking soft and glowy but not feeling like I have a ton of powder. But I would imagine that if your skin is on the dry side, a cream or liquid would work better. HTH