At least for me, I think Subculture is moreso, though I think they are pretty similar - it's very flesh-toned and on me, it's almost the exact same shade as my lips.
On my lips, Dervish is more natural. My lips are really pink, so Dervish just kind of evens them out and gives them definition. I tried Subculture, and didn't think much of it.
Dervish is a little darker even on my pigmented lips, but Whirl actually matches mine to the T...would Whirl work better for you? Or are you looking for a darker liner than that? Because then I would say Dervish would probably work best....