I love masks! It makes me feel like I am at Spa night. I like the peel offs for exfoliation (Freeman's, about 4 bucks, a steal!). I make a mask of crushed aspirin and egg white for acne and inflammation (hammer, plastic baggie or crucible) and I like mud masks. Most of the clay masks I loved like Olay's Blue Clay and Aveeno have been discontinued. I love the NARS Mud mask! St Ives was too thin and runny for me.... Queen Helene's Mint Julip is inexpensive and a bit irritating but it sucks out the oil nicely.Neutrogena has an Acne mask with salcylic acid-don't leave it on longer than 10 minutes...but you can dab it on a pimple overnight and its gone in the a.m.. DDF makes a nice Sulfur Mask that is mild and does not smell like rotten eggs. Alba makes a clear gel exfoliating mask-Papaya Enzyme Mask-it is only left on 10 minutes, its a great exfoliator. There were a lot of good sea mud and seaweed masks a few years ago that were discontinued, I donn't know why....the ones on the market now are so hit or miss,
Now the St Ives Firming Clay mask is very gentle. It does not have a lot of active ingrediants so if you used that particular brand, it would not overdry you. If you used one with salcylic acid everyday, it might cause some inflammation. (There are no ingrediants in the St Ives Mask that will firm skin, however....)