lure eyeshadows...

[Shavwi]

I can afford three of 'em - what do you guys suggest? Already have Black Tied and don't want Idol Eyes. I'm torn between the other 4

Which ones are necessary to you guys? thanks!

 

[pumpkincat210]

mancatcher, aquavert and waternymph. Sea Myth was too similar to seedy pearl and almond icing.

 

[BlahWah]

You can pass on Waternymph if you have Steamy (close match) or Tease n Teal (almost exactly the same), though if you can get a 2nd, I'd say get it =P. Aquavert is a pretty green foam colour, but Mancatcher is one you'd probably use more, and it seems pretty different from the current shadows available.

HTH!

*edit* Oops, I misread, I thought you were only getting one. I 2nd all of pumpkincat's recs.

 

[AudreyNicole]

Quote:

Originally Posted by pumpkincat210 mancatcher, aquavert and waternymph. Sea Myth was too similar to seedy pearl and almond icing.

My thoughts exactly! I only got these three, and am quite pleased with them

 

[Shavwi]

thanks so much ladies! I just ordered Waternymph, Aquavert adn Mancatcher

I can't wait until they come in!

 

[scrapbookromance]

how is mancatcher pronounced? I'm thinking its said man-catcher, like one who catches a man ha. I feel dumb going to MAC and mispronouncing the names because I've only read them and not heard them.

 

[koolmnbv]

Quote:

Originally Posted by pumpkincat210 mancatcher, aquavert and waternymph. Sea Myth was too similar to seedy pearl and almond icing.

2nd these, you could ALWAYS get seedy pearl later on because its permanent. And if you swatch them they are VERY close I can see no diffrence imo they are identical but some ppl can see a slight difference but not enough to miss out on 1 of the other brighter Lure colors.

also some ppl. are saying waternymph can be duped but tease n teal (which is very close to waternymph) was also LE and the other permanent close lookalikes are still enough difference imo to justify buying waternymph.

Anyway I agree with pumpkincat210 on the 3 she chose!

 

[divaster]

Quote:

Originally Posted by scrapbookromance how is mancatcher pronounced? I'm thinking its said man-catcher, like one who catches a man ha. I feel dumb going to MAC and mispronouncing the names because I've only read them and not heard them.

That's how I said it to the MA yesterday. I said I need *held up e/s pot* one Mancatcher. He says "honey, we all need one of those".

That MA was awesome. I'm going to that counter more often.

 

[kimb]

hahaha thats funny!!! I am getting ready to go to the MAC counter now!!! Im excited

 

[scrapbookromance]

Quote:

Originally Posted by divaster I said I need *held up e/s pot* one Mancatcher. He says "honey, we all need one of those".

haha

that made my night! especially since I got the e/s today. maybe when I wear it I'll catch myself some guys! (just don't tell the boyfriend!)

 

[jacqdingle]

so mancatcher,aquavert and waternymph should be on my list?!?!hopefully, lure collection from MAC will be here in our country..but i guess i have to wait for ages....were always LATE...when it comes to MAC collections..grrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!

 

[foxyqt]

I'd get Waternymph, Aquavert and Mancatcher too =)

 

[tinkerbelle]

Aquavert is such a pretty color.

 

[pugmommy7]

waternymph and aquavert!!

 

[bellaetoile]

i got waternymph, mancatcher, and sea myth. i thought aquavert looked too wierd and chalky on my nc42 skin. although i'd recommend delphic and haunting fluidline over any of the shadows, personally. i just didn't feel that the shadows were anything special, really.

 

[kimmy]

Waternymph, Aquavert and Mancatcher...because like everyone said, you can pick up Seedy Pearl, which is alot like Sea Myth, anytime.

 

[talk2mesun]

waternymph if u can just get one
aquavert too if you can get two

 

[geeko]

hi girls...i was playing with my lure e/s today. i noticed that if i layer waternymph over mancatcher i'll a a light blue colour. looks great though....esp when mancatcher is worn in the inner lid and waternymph is worn on the outer lid mancatcher. it because purple and blue colour

 

[xiahe]

Quote:

Originally Posted by pumpkincat210 mancatcher, aquavert and waternymph. Sea Myth was too similar to seedy pearl and almond icing.

yes! unless you don't have seedy pearl or almond icing, then you can get a dupe of it in the cute turquoise/blue packaging...

but i'd stick with mancatcher, aquavert & waternymph. they're all so pretty!