MAC eyeliner recs please

[SweetCheeks]

I am smitten with MAC fluidline in Graphic Brown or Bobbi Brown gel in Chocolate Shimmer ... is there an eyeliner by MAC that stays put, has the same color payoff, yet is in a pencil-like form out there? In similar shade?

Thank you !

 

[TISH1124]

I like Teddy...Not sure if that is still available but it is a Chocolate brown

 

[SweetCheeks]

I love Teddy too, it would be perfect except it's a kohl so it's staying power isn't great like fluidline.

 

[TISH1124]

Yeah I don't think most pencil are.....I do think Spare Change looks great...but I haven't tried it yet