MAC Fake Pigment Comparison - Shimmertime and Sweet Sienna Vs. Dark Soul

Mui

Active member
I'm sort of new here on Specktra.net and I usually hang around the Counterfeit MAC section on the forums.

When I first got into pigments, I religiously read the guides on how to identify fake/counterfeit pigments. I would first off like to thank the lovely ladies that took time out of their day to create the guides for all of us because it really does take a lot of effort.

Recently I bought several pigments from a girl (not through Ebay) and I happened to recieve a fake pigment (a.k.a. Dark Soul pigment) and because I was inspired by the guides created before, I decided to do one as well.
Just to be helpful to the Specktra community and to return the favour to those who helped me.
smiles.gif


Edit: I just wanted to add that this is what I learned and have picked up but there is a possibility that I can be wrong. I won't say I am 100% correct but this is what I seem to have found.

Also not all pigments are going to have the little booklet on the back of the boxes. I specifically chose Shimmertime pigment because it did have the booklet and I wanted to do a comparison of the booklet.

Enjoy!

The guide involves the following pigments:
Shimmertime pigment - Batch code: A16
Sweet Sienna pigment - Batch code: A67
Dark Soul pigment - Batch code: A66

Also I accidentally forgot the comparison of the fonts on the front of the pigment jars so I'll have to add that in once I find my camera cord. I'll add swatch comparisons after I get my real Dark Soul pigment.


comparisonpic1.jpg

comparisonpic2.jpg

comparisonpic3.jpg

comparisonpic4.jpg

comparisonpic5.jpg

comparisonpic6.jpg

comparisonpic7.jpg

comparisonpic8.jpg

comparisonpic9.jpg

comparisonpic10.jpg
 

Sojourner

Well-known member
The only thing that was obvious to me in that comparison is the sticker on the top. I don't think I could tell the rest for myself, it's too confusing and frustrating to work out what's real and what's not
ssad.gif
 

TheCollector

Well-known member
I am confused by your first picture, showing the top of the authentic shimmertime box. Isn't the location of the sticker wrong?? I am sooo confused...
 

Mui

Active member
No, the sticker isn't in the wrong place.
I have many real MAC pigments, and they aren't always in the same spot. The stickers are usually around the upper right area of the box top.

In my picture - I clearly state the difference in materials of the sticker itself.
 
Top