Mac Fluidline vs Estee Lauder Purecolor Eyeliner

[mary peterson]

Hi guys!

Im just wondering if you have tried Estee's Liquid eyeliner. Ive always had it. It stays and doesnt budge. The one ive got is a gorgeous deep black.

Since Ive been reading that most of you use mac fluidliners,
do you think that I should try it?

For those of you who have tried both Estee's liquid liner and Mac fluidliner, which one do you prefer?

And while Im at it, any recs for eyeliner that wont smear and stay in place in the water line?

thanks gals

 

[VioletB]

To be honest with you I think they Estee Lauder liner stays on a little better (on me anyway) however, it makes my eyes burn (I don't know why.. I work for Lauder and it's the only product I can't use!) I like fluidline but sometimes it flakes a little if you get it too think. If you love the Lauder stuff stick with it. That's what I tell people. If you love something why give it up.

 

[VioletB]

One more thing.. I forgot the waterline. I like the automatic eyeliner duo for that. I just use Jet Black. It's by Lauder too

 

[mary peterson]

thanks violet! i'll check out their eyepencil.

 

[hunnybun]

i agree -- the estee lauder liquid stays way better. fluidline smudges on me a bit, esp now that it's warm.

another product you can try for the water line is jet set waterproof eyeliner by smashbox. it comes in a creme consistency (kind of like the fluidlines) but is completely waterproof and smudge proof and formulated to be safe for the waterline. they also sell an angled liner brush that is perfect for you waterline.

hth!