I have to agree with posts saying the evil eye quad is not that bad. I stopped by MAC yesterday to swatch a few things and ended up getting both quads, midnight blues, & 3 shadesticks. The evil eye quad shows up well & with decent pigmentation when layered over a paint pot. I used it over painterly today, along with prance & blanc type, and I really like the look. I agree that it is not an A+ palette or the best thing that MAC has ever released. I certainly wouldn't call it the worst though. I am NW 20, and I like that I can build up the color.