mac penned f/l or mac waveline or Bobbie Brown saphire?

[poppy z]

Hello,

I'm looking for a dark blue fluidline (like Shade f/l for a dark green).
I really love the mac eyeliner gel because I used it as an eye shadow base.
I tested the BB saphire on my hand and I found it very beautiful (I love the shimmer). But I don't know this product. Isn't it dry or is it just the same thing as mac fluidline (not for the price ...)?
So, I'm hesitate between the 2 mac fluidlines: waveline / penned (from patternmaker collection) and the BB.
Please help me
Thx a lot

 

[Juneplum]

moved to recs.. k, imHo... bb gel liner is better than mac's.. don't get me wrong, i like the f/l, but bb had them long before f/l came out and they are awesome! she has really nice colors and i prefer the gellish texture..

 

[BlahWah]

I don't know much about the BB line, but if you're looking for a blue as Shade is for greens, get Penned. Waveline is vibrant and brighter, whereas Penned is a bit muted and darker.

Slightly OT, but I wish there'd be a "Waveline" for greens. =P Shade's sometimes a bit too muted.