I love the matte finish. I think they look more natural on their own, and balance out a frosty/shimmery look. My favorites:
Malt (a light grayish pink, the color of the inside of malted milk ball)
Cork (warm, soft brown, a beautiful crease color to use with frosts)
Behold (grayish brown)
Stencil (warm, soft peach, another pretty crease color)
Blackberry (deep violetish purple)
Blu Noir (deep blue, great for lining)
Brun (dark brown, great for lining)
Electro Sky (bright blue)
Green Tea (from the Sweet tea quad, a dark brownish green)
I'm NC20, light brown hair, with hazel eyes for reference