i would get a refund. for full price, you are entitled to get a whole product, in saleable condition. even though the mineralize duos do break easily, same with any baked mineral product, perhaps mac should have taken better precautions when shipping them. hopefully, you'll find the colors you want in them, as i've seen a few of them go up for sale around specktra, MUA, livejournal, and ebay. but in my opinion, definately, you should get a full refund from mac.