Need final addition to my basic MAC "travel" quad

[vicuna1]

My basic, do anything, goes with everything, absolute perfection for my coloring combo is:
Vex, Expensive Pink and Club
However, I need a 4th shade to make a travel quad. Something deeper for evening and lining. Something w/some color. I own Nocturnelle and Au Contraire as possibilities, but have been considering buying Plumage, too.

Opinions? Any and all other options are appreciated. I would prefer not to use Black Tied, Beauty Mark or Carbon as these can be a little harsh for me. I've considered pigments as options, but have a problem making them stay in the palette, LOL! So I would prefer a pan.

Thanks all!

 

[MACattack]

I REALLY love Femme Noir. That's an alternative to the traditional black... also, maybe...

*Blu-Noir
*Nehru
*Shadowy Lady

HTH! Good luck... I LOOOOOOVE Expensive Pink... have you used it as a blush yet? FANTASTIC!

 

[Hikaru-chan]

How about Rummy?

 

[crimsonette]

hmmm... Intoxicate? maybe a bit too dark.