Night Affair vs Phosphorelle/Elle

[stellarx1587]

Is Night Affair significantly different from Phosphorelle/Elle? I was thinking about getting it, but held off until I could get the final verdict here on Specktra. Its just that I already have Phosphorelle & Elle... so I don't wanna get it if it looks similar.

 

[MAC_Whore]

Night Affair is a cool, whereas Phosphorelle is a warm.

Night Affair is REALLY sheer. It has pink pearl and a bit of blue pearl to it. Barely any colour.

Elle is a bit more opaque with gold pearl and LOTS of red pearl. Elle is much more present on the lips than Night Affair is.

I love Elle/Phosphorelle, but Night Affair is just....meh...kinda OK. Honestly, I would skip the Night Affair. Just my two pence.

 

[kimmy]

ITA with MAC_Whore! she said it perfectly

i just posted a swatch in the Nocturnelle thread in the swatch forum of Night Affair, that might help make up your mind

 

[Hauddi77]

I bought Night Affair, it really looks alot like Oyster Girl. Meh....I wasn't impressed

 

[tiramisu]

I still loves my Snowgirl l/g and I'm not straying!!

 

[princess]

If you can still get it, get Phosphorelle/Elle instead. Night Affair is a far cry from it.