I would suggest keeping make up away from it for a while. It's not that make up shouldn't touch the area, I actually don't know anything about that. But I know from personal experience that when healing, the area gets aggravated very easily. See the thing is, the area is prone to getting "the bump", aka keloids, so the only time you touch the piercing should be when you're cleaning it morning and night. It might seemed healed to you right away, at least it did to me, but I think the healing time is around two months?
I got 'the bump' TWICE in that first 2-3 months. The first time it happened because it felt healed so I touched it a LOT. I did warm salt water soaks for weeeeks to get rid of it but I had to go on vacation for a week and I forgot to bring the salt. It was gone by the time I came back home! I realized leaving it alone is the way to go so I stopped my usual routine and just used antibacterial soap twice a day. The second time, it got caught on the towel when I was drying my face... ouch. I used pure tea tree oil on the area twice a day which worked like magic.
It's actually not that hard to apply the make up around the piercing and the results are not that noticeable. When I first got it, I just naturally and instinctively avoided that area and my friend who was watching me put on my makeup told me that I was doing that. I'm sure you'll figure it out too. Maybe use a smaller brush around it?