Hey hun, I've got crazy oily skin, too, and nothing I tried worked until I scaled back my skincare a bit...what I've started doing is washing my face at night, applying all my acne stuff, and spritzing myself with Fix + (because of my treatments, I can't put moisturizer on, it just balls up and looks gross) to keep my skin hydrated. Then in the morning I use an alcohol-free toner to clean my face and remove the residue from my treatments. I use a good moisturizer with SPF after that, and my skin has significantly improved.
Basically, your skin may be producing excess oil to make up for the moisture that your cleanser and toner are sucking out of it. You may want to try using the cleanser at night (make sure you get some moisture on your skin afterward, be it moisturizer, or Fix + or something), and the toner in the morning (make sure you moisturize after this too!). Give it about a week and see if your skin balances out a bit. My skin isn't completely oil-free, but since I've been doing this little routine, it's improved by leaps and bounds. HTH!!