I guess it depends on what you want it for. I personally prefer Petticoat. But Naked You is growing on me, so i couldn't tell you! I like petticoat mostly on my cheeks, but in the summer when I'm more tanned i'll probably use it all over! Naked You Is not pink like Petticoat, its a pale nude and could be used allover anytime..Its more sparkly than Petticoat. I think they are both nice and very different.