On me, I have both Charm Factor and Pink Cabana, and both are very different. I haven't found anything close to PC in the MAC line, but I find Maybelline's Wet Shine Diamonds l/s in Fair Maiden is similar as well as Cover Girl's Smoothers l/l in Rosegold Glow (but I think that's been discontinued). If you find PC in eBay tho, try to pick it up, cuz even those two suggestions aren't as gorgeous!