So I was on hold for 95 minutes waiting for a CS rep.
http://img225.imageshack.us/img225/5174/photo34fv5.jpg
See that? It says 92:02
But anyway, I was finally connected. The CS rep was actually really helpful and sympathetic to my situation. I made sure to say I had the receipt, I bought it in February, about why I didn't start using it until recently (perm), and that I just wanted an exchange. I also mentioned that I bought it at another store and she said that it wouldn't have mattered. She sounded sort of angry at my experience. She told me that the exchange should have been made and the only time they could have refused it is if I abused the iron by banging it or whatever and not using it for it's intended use. Which in my case it was not as everything was in the box, unfilled register cards, used only a total of 3 times. She asked me if I dealt with a manager or SA and I told her that I believe the woman was a manager since she decided to take it up to the regional manager. She told me, "See if it was an SA, I would honestly have to tell you that a lot of times, most of them don't know what they're talking about". But, it was a manager (I strongly believe). So she tells me she'll put me on hold or call me back and I told her to just do whatever's easiest for her. So she gets me number, and calls me back fairly quickly. During that break, she called the store, and said that they said "OOhhh we know our policy, we would have done the exchange for her". And she also told me that the store manager was there right now and would notify the other managers about a girl wanting to exchange a hot pink t3 iron.
So I also mentioned to her when she called me back, because I forgot since I was laying there waiting for 95 minutes..., that the woman also gave me an attitude and talked to me as if I were a delinquent. I also mentioned the 90 day crap that she pulled out of her butt and said that I'm not one to argue with a policy if it's stated in black and white on the receipt but I see nothing about 90 day anything and the CS rep agreed with me. I told her that she could have made it up for all I know and she told me "She did. We don't have anything in our policy about 90 days".
She advised me to report her once I go back to Ulta to the manager in charge, unless she happens to be the manager, and if so, to get her name and call CS back.
Also, she said that if they don't do the exchange, to call CS directly from the store.
So I will be back to Ulta later on today.