Project Runway Season 4 spoilers :)
- Thread starter astronaut
- Start date
triccc
Well-known member
Quote:
christian V siriano collection
MySpace.com - Christian - 22 - Male - New York , New York - www.myspace.com/christiansiriano
Originally Posted by amoona
I love Christian and I'm glad he won but I still feel like Rami's clothing is much more wearable. Does he have a website featuring his work?! |
christian V siriano collection
MySpace.com - Christian - 22 - Male - New York , New York - www.myspace.com/christiansiriano
FullWroth
Well-known member
I honestly don't get the big deal about Christian's collection or the fact that he won. Wow, a jacket over skinny pants. How innovative. All he's done all season is jacket + skinny pants, and/or ruffly dress. And aside from the 3 dresses in his collection, that's pretty much all he did. Rami got crap for doing the same thing over and over again, but when Christian does it, it's fresh and hip and young? Whatever, man. If you're gonna give one guy crap for sticking to the same pattern, you really need to give the second guy the same crap for it too.
I was rooting for Rami or Gillian, personally. Their collections were way more diverse AND way more wearable than Christian's. About the only thing I thought was pretty cool in Christian's collection was the feather dress, but one cool, unwearable dress in a monotonous, largely-unwearable collection should not beat out two beautiful, diverse, wearable collections, IMO.
I was rooting for Rami or Gillian, personally. Their collections were way more diverse AND way more wearable than Christian's. About the only thing I thought was pretty cool in Christian's collection was the feather dress, but one cool, unwearable dress in a monotonous, largely-unwearable collection should not beat out two beautiful, diverse, wearable collections, IMO.
athena123
Well-known member
The judges decision to give Christian the win truly, truly eludes me. Throughout the season the feedback they pounded Chris with was that his work was too "costumey". Um, and you mean Christian's over the top designs aren't? The only place you can wear his stuff is to a freaking costume or theme party for christ sake! The judges also harrassed Rami relentlessly about being a "one-note" and they had a point at that, but why didn't this criticism apply to Christian's constant flow of skinny bottoms, overly ruffled tops and monotonous color scheme? The real one-note proved to be little wonderboy.
I was rooting for Jillian to win and some of her innovations just really took my breath away; I can see myself wearing a lot of her looks. Imagine my surprise that I actually liked Rami's collection the best. It was cohesive, he broke out of the grecian draping mode we were subjected to all season and he truly introduced something NEW. That second optical dress was absolutely stellar, and I can see myself in a lot of his clothing as well.
I'm sure we haven't heard the last of either Rami or Jillian they're both excellant designers. Christian's collection was a true yawn.
I was rooting for Jillian to win and some of her innovations just really took my breath away; I can see myself wearing a lot of her looks. Imagine my surprise that I actually liked Rami's collection the best. It was cohesive, he broke out of the grecian draping mode we were subjected to all season and he truly introduced something NEW. That second optical dress was absolutely stellar, and I can see myself in a lot of his clothing as well.
I'm sure we haven't heard the last of either Rami or Jillian they're both excellant designers. Christian's collection was a true yawn.
