Recc's for a dark neutral quad

[Kristen]

I want to expand my e/s collection and actually get some neutrals. I'm considering getting Too Faced's Peep Show, Stila's Must Haves or making my own from MAC. I was looking at the top 10 neutrals.. and many of them seem really light or just highlighters (at least for me, a NC35). If you could recommend 4 colours for a quad or give a review on Peep Show or Must Haves that would help a lot. Thanks.

 

[Hawkeye]

Mystery
Kid
Smolder
Browndown?

 

[macdoll]

vanilla or ricepaper (highlight)
kid or era (medium color)
bark (crease)
embark (contour or liner)

 

[saj20052006]

Neutrals

Saddle, Embark, Mulch, Cork, BrownDown, Brun. Also try a deeper base with some of the highlighter colors, such as Naturalism.