Shroom or Naked Lunch if you had to pick one only?

[Sushi_Flower]

and why?

Oh and are these 2 universal colours for any skin tone or is there another colour which does the same job but better suited to darker tones?

 

[AlliSwan]

Shroom is better for lighter skin and cooler tones, naked lunch is a bit darker and warmer.

 

[ette]

I'd say Shroom is a better highlighter.

 

[Jennifer Mcfly]

When I first got Naked Lunch I loved it! Then I got Shroom...and although my love for NL has not died, Shroom is just a wee bit more versatile.

 

[litlaur]

I think Naked Lunch would be better for darker skintones.

 

[pushhupsindrag]

shroom totally for lighter. naked lunch for darker.

 

[Jude]

Both

 

[mandirigma]

Depends on what you're using it for, I guess? Shroom is my HG highlighter and I'm an NC40. Naked Lunch goes on way too shimmery as a highlighter and kind of makes me look like a raccoon, but it's a nice regular color.

 

[Miss_Behave]

none for highlight for me, they are both too dark and too shimmery. for highlight I use vanilla or vapor.
If I have to choose one for lid color: naked lunch

 

[canadiangirl_1117]

Hmm...tough choice. I love Naked Lunch for an all-over wash with Mulch in the crease for a neutral look, but Shroom is awesome for highlighting and for a really subtle eye.

But if I had to pick just one, Naked Lunch.

 

[aziajs]

Naked Lunch all the way. Like the above posters said, it's better for darker skin, which I have.

 

[d_flawless]

i use both, for different colors though...shroom is probably a little more versatile though, since NL has pink in it

 

[Midgard]

Definitely Naked Lunch for darker skintones!

 

[leppy]

I think shroom is warmer but thats jmo, I like both.. shroom is more a perfect nude on my pale skin tho. TBH I think they are great together if you want a NARS AAE type of look.

Of my friends, those of us who are NC15-25, we all use shroom as our nude, the NC35s and darker use Naked Lunch. There you have it!

 

[Hikaru-chan]

Naked Lunch is much better suited on darker skin.

 

[anuy]

naked lunch is gorgeous... shroom is way too light for me.

but you have to keep in mind that naked lunch is a frost texture meaning its a way more frosty look and shroom is more sheer... that is why some people love shroom and other love naked lunch.

i think theyre different enough to have both

 

[anuy]

oh, and im NC 42

 

[ledonatella]

I've said it before and I'll say it again, I HATE Shroom! I'm NC20 and it just disappears on me, blends right into my skin and has a weird grey cast to it on me. I do like Naked Lunch and I use it as a highlighter sometimes, but honestly I use Jest or Hush or Phloof more often then Naked Lunch.

 

[Cleopatra]

Shroom. It is great for highlighting under brows and is perfect to apply underneath or over other colours to tone down some brightness.

 

[Isis]

I'm very pale (nw15), and I prefer Naked Lunch over Shroom. I maybe b/c it has an once more color to it than Shroom does.